MPIP: Melanoma Patients Information Page

The MPIP is the oldest and largest community of people affected by melanoma hosted through the Melanoma Research Foundation. It is designed to provide support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. Once you have been touched by melanoma—either as a patient or as a family member or friend of a patient—you become part of a community. It is not a community anyone joins willingly. But if you must be part of this group, you will find no better place to find the tools you need in your journey with this cancer, and the friends who can make that journey more bearable.

The information on the bulletin board is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide by MRF posting policies.

Expand/ Collapse Topic
Replies By
View Topic
Rita and Charles's picture
Replies 8
Last reply 8/1/2016 - 10:24pm

After 9 months on Braf Combo, my husband was suffering still with such nausea and joint pain that he stopped.  He was 2 1/2 months without meds and we feared the worst PET Scan results.  The oncologists were as surprised as we were relieved - no progression, still stable!  The only thing that happened within the 2 months off is that he developed vitilligo..........but the good results are what we really loved.

The Combo worked!  We don't have scans scheduled now until October :)  Vacation from worry worry worry and fear......for now!


Login or register to post replies.

A friend with stage 4 melanoma went through Ipilimumab treatment, but he subsequently had some new tumors show up. He was then put on the combination Dabrafenib and Tramethinib. His tumors are now escaping these enzyme blockers. His oncologist is now proposing to test him to see if Keytruda will work for him.

I didn't know there were markers that could predict Keytruda response. What are they?

Thanks for your help.

Login or register to post replies.

Sorry to be posting again but I have more questions ....

background Stage 3a ~ do not qualify for clinical trial, only 1 lymph node positive, BRAF negative

was told interferon was my only option

was told I "don't want to do Yervoy, Stage 3 dosage too toxic"


I called my insurance company to see if any adjuvant therapy is covered by my insurance.

Yervoy ~ 10 ml is covered but needs pre-authorization

Keytruda ~ covered, no pre-authorization needed, $25 for 21 day supply

Opdivo ~ covered, no pre-authorization needed, $25 for 21 day supply


Am I mising something?? 


Login or register to post replies.

BrianP's picture
Replies 3
Last reply 7/20/2016 - 12:57am
Replies by: Bubbles, Georgi524, JoshF

May be some time before we reap the benefits of this but it's comforting to know smart guys like Ribas are working on and making some discoveries on why some patients have some tumors that respond to immunotherapy while other tumors grow and why some patients recur.

Login or register to post replies.

Patrick O.'s picture
Replies 14
Last reply 7/30/2016 - 12:13pm

Hello all. Just diagnosed with stage IV as of 7/13. Am seeing my OCL for the first time on 7/20. Just wondering what are a few of the most important things I need to ask him about.
I've been reading many of these posts and it has been a great source of info and hope.


Login or register to post replies.

ecc26's picture
Replies 4
Last reply 7/19/2016 - 3:21pm
Replies by: ecc26, jamieth29, JoshF, Polymath

Been a pretty rough week… or so.

Had a pretty good week with family at a reunion from the 3rd to the 9th except for tripping and falling on the sidewalk on our way to a parade on the 4th and badly skinning my knee. Between that and some of the medications I’m on I had a harder time doing things like getting down to the water (steep stairs and supposed to stay out of the sun). Felt at times a bit like the grinch who didn’t want to do anything. My little sister and her fiancé got married on Thursday and we had a great reception Friday with LOTS of great food, family and neighbors. We also celebrated my parent’s anniversary (late, but that’s ok) with a special dinner out. Lots of good things happened that week. 

Unfortunately, as the week went on, I started to notice a return of my back pain, despite the fact that I was walking and doing my physical therapy stretches/exercises. That didn’t help my grinchiness and I attributed it to the overly soft mattress we were sleeping on at the rental house. Between my skinned knee (hurt whenever anything touched it) and my back I was not sleeping very well and was pretty tired and grumpy by the time we left on Saturday morning. Made worse by the thought of a long car ride (not great for my back).

By the end of the week we had eaten so much and so much cured/salted meat (bacon, sausage, etc) that my feet and ankles were swollen, so after picking up our diabetic cat from a friend and doing some housework (good amount of NSAIDs on board for my back) and running a couple of errands (empty fridge) I settled down on the couch to elevate my swollen feet and apply some of the techniques I learned from the physical therapist for lymphedema in my arm to try and clear the fluid from my feet/ankles. Relaxed and watching TV I was interrupted by another focal motor seizure in my right arm. The last couple had been pretty mild and short lived, so other than being annoyed that they were still happening despite the anti-seizure meds and having the brain mets treated, I didn’t think much of it. I already had an appointment with my local oncologist coming up on Friday. Assuming no other problems, I would discuss it with him then. 

Problem was, it wasn’t stopping- it would ease up and I would think it was about to stop, then increase in intensity and keep going. No idea how long it went on for, but I got scared and called for my husband (upstairs). He found me on the couch and called an ambulance (poor guy, can’t even imagine how he must have been feeling). Of course right after he hung up the phone it stopped, but I had no use of my right arm at all it was so fatigued. The ambulance arrived, but given that it was done we opted to just have my husband drive me down to the ER for evaluation. The EMTs took my blood pressure, My husband had to sign all the paperwork both for the ambulance and at the ER and we now have a $170 dollar bill for the EMTs blood pressure reading (which was a little high, but not abnormal). Just kidding, I know the fee is for responding to the call and would have been much higher had I taken the ride.

So, spent Sunday evening in the ER again, where they did a CT and lots of bloodwork. That showed that I had low potassium, magnesium, and that I was anemic (shocker-I've had anemia forever). They infused 2mg Mg, almost forgot to flush my port before de-accessing it, and gave me a couple of pills to take to get my potassium back to normal. The neurologist on call reported that low Mg levels can cause seizure activity, so who knows- maybe that was all it was. In the mean time, several hours on an ER bed did nothing good for my back, which felt like I had been set back all the way to when it started last fall.

Lots of NSADs later trying to get my back pain under control, and, surprise surprise, started having GI issues; you know, because steroids and NSAIDs go so well together. Typically a day or 2 of carefully timed NSAIDs and I don’t have any problems, but with the continued setbacks with my back pain the NSAID use was going on longer than expected. I had some narcotics I probably could have used, but given how loopy and nauseous they make me and how non-functional I become I tend to avoid them. It’s better for muscular problems to be able to get up and move around than to be stuck in a non-functional state- hence the preference for NSAIDs.

Seemed like an outflow obstruction issue in my stomach where anything I ate or drank would sit in my stomach forever. Also, with the complete setback in my hand/arm I was frustrated by not having the dexterity to even cut my own meat- my husband had to do that for me like I was a child. As the week progressed I started having what seemed like gastritis/ulcer symptoms in addition (assumption NSAIDs and steroids together longer than normal).
Appointment with local oncologist Friday afternoon where I discussed the changes and setbacks. No big surprise, he wanted me to stop the NSAIDs and go to narcotics only. After some arguing about being able to function and nausea associated with those, we compromised on narcotics at night when I’ll be sleeping anyway and tylenol or advil during the day to be functional, but only if needed for back pain. Looking at the bloodwork from the ER visit and considering the other symptoms I’d developed he also decided to hospitalize me and do a blood transfusion and a chest/abdomen/pelvis CT. Can’t say I was excited about any of that and was pretty grumpy between the side effects of the meds I was already on, lack of sleep from the back and stomach pain and having to spend an unexpected night in a hospital bed, which I knew would not help my back. My poor husband had to go home and get me pj’s and I had him stop and get sandwiches for after the CT. I really do feel bad for all that I put him through.
Checked in to the hospital, they accessed my port, but then tried to put in a peripheral catheter for the CT- which I refused to let them do (that’s why I have a port). Drew blood, started the blood transfusion as I started drinking the GI contrast, and started going over a questionnaire and possible side effects from the transfusion. The nurse wanted a complete history of my surgeries, etc (all in my file, should have been able to look that up) with the end result being that they came to get me for CT before any of that was done. Nurse said we’d finish everything when I came back, but when I came back nothing else happened and there was no paperwork about the blood transfusion left in the room for me to look at. Shift change was happening and I was more interested in whether or not I was allowed to eat, so by the time I thought about it there wasn’t much to do as the transfusion was continuing. 
They gave me some injection for the stomach pain, which was great and allowed me to eat the sandwich. My husband had to go home around 9 to deal with our diabetic cat, and after that the overnight nurse gave me an injectable anti-nausea followed by a narcotic, which hit before he was done injecting it. It certainly does relieve pain, but boy was I dizzy. Thank goodness for anti-nausea meds. I just basically went to sleep.
Hospitals are not known for being restful places and between the frequent vital signs checks for the transfusion (the 2 units didn’t end until after midnight) and the regular vitals checks every few hours, I got very little sleep. Local oncologist came in Sat morning, said the scan did not show any evidence of an outflow obstruction and no bleeding ulcer, but something about a segment of intestine that was doubled back on itself (still not quite sure what this means) that was probably causing some of the gastric issues. He indicated that the GI contrast often resolves that. It hasn’t as far as I can tell.
I was discharged with a script for a muscle relaxant, the narcotic I had gotten at the hospital and the anti-nausea medication. Of those 3, which do you think the insurance had a problem with and I couldn’t get filled? That’s right, the anti-nausea medication. In addition, pretty much all the medications I’m now on (except the steroid) cause dizziness and/or drowsiness. Great.
Along with the Ipi/PD-1 infusion (second infusion happening as I type) getting IV Fe instead, and after a conversation with my oncologist this morning before the infusion started, the Dexamethasone will be cut back to 1mg once a day instead of twice, so hopefully that will help my stomach.
In general, if I didn’t have the back pain that keeps getting exacerbated then I probably wouldn’t have the stomach issues. My knee at least is healing well. but I really could do with at least one less problem and a few less pills in my life. I’m tired and frustrated with everything and haven’t had a moment to explore what might come next if this doesn’t work. I’m also overly emotional from… who knows what- lack of sleep, stress, frustration, medications, all of it… and who knows what side effects I’ll get from this second infusion of 2 drugs I’ve already failed. Can’t wait. Hopefully I’ll get the back pain settled, the follow up MRI in a few weeks will look good and I can get off some of these pills. Right now that may be the best I can hope for.
If you’ve read all the way through this, you’re probably feeling drowsy yourself. I apologize for that. 

Login or register to post replies.

Randy437's picture
Replies 7
Last reply 7/20/2016 - 4:19am

I am now 6+ years NED after mets to brain, lungs and small intestine.  Both brain MRI and body CT + blood work were negative today.  So I'm moving to scans every 6 months from every 3/4 months.  Onc said one factor was that I've never "failed" a treatment - mets were surgically removed (brain met followed up with GammaKnife).  It seems there are no standard protocols for long term stage IV survivors - it's an individual decision between patient and doc.  At ten years, we'll revist (knock on wood).

Login or register to post replies.

Lee Parlier's picture
Replies 13
Last reply 7/19/2016 - 6:11am

I am trying to learn as much as possible from the experiences of others when choosing treatment options when you are stage 3 or 4. My personal experience has been that Dr.s shy away from yervoy and recommend interferon. There is an emphasis with the toxicity and the side effects of yervoy. 

I am not sure if I am over simplifying things but I don't understand why the potential side effects are a reason to stear a patient from the treatment if it is in fact the best option to become NED or at least increase OSR. I know immunotherapy isn't a guarantee to beat melanoma but it sures seems like a better option than interferon. 

My Dr.s options given to me:





I chose Yervoy 10 mg and he tried for a week to get me to change my mind. I have currently finished 3 doses with minimal side effects yet. I know they may kick my butt soon but very happy I gave yervoy a chance. I don't know what tomorrow holds but I want what I feel gives me the best chances NOT what the Dr. feels is the traditional treatment because noone dies from it. 

I am curious for the input of people that have had similar experiences when choosing treatment or adjuvant therapies. 

Lee Parlier

Login or register to post replies.

Kare83's picture
Replies 1
Last reply 7/18/2016 - 6:00am
Replies by: Anonymous

I have a commin mole (dome shaped) on my forehead. It's been there since I was little. Over the years it has grown a little. I have bumped it in the past, brushed it, accidentally hit it etc and it has never been a problem, however in the past week it has bled a handful of times, all without bumping or touching it.

I had a stage 1 melanoma removed from my back last year. I will make a appointment and hopefully see my Dr this week, just wondering if anyone has had a common mole bleed for no apparent reason?

Login or register to post replies.

mrsaxde's picture
Replies 1
Last reply 7/18/2016 - 3:54pm
Replies by: Mat

Hi Everyone!

I haven't had much time to read or post here lately. I hope things are going well for all of you.

I just had my 17th (I think) infusion of Keytruda yesterday. My last scan in April was good...spots on my back are stable, with one being slightly larger (9mm vs 7mm in January), but my oncologist thinks that may be due to a different radiologist reading this scan. She says visibly they don't appear to be any different to her. As of that scan the spots in my lung continue to slowly decrease in size, and nothing new has appeared. My doctor was happy enough with my results that she decided to postpone my next scan for a month, so I'll get it done in August now instead of this month.

One thing that has concerned me a bit eosinophil count seems to be returning to normal. I've read and been told a fair amount about high eosinophils being a marker for response to immunotherapy, so the fact that my EOS Absolute level is now within normal values after being elevated the entire time I've been receiving Keytruda is a bit concerning. I'm worried that my response may be coming to an end. (My EOS Auto level is stil high, though.) I've also been much less itchy in recent weeks, and my oncologist has told me in the past that "itchy is good."

So I'm curious about a couple of things.

1) Has anyone else had a similar experience? That is, had elevated eosinophils that returned to normal during treatment. If so, what did that mean for your response?

2) If you got an initial response to Keytruda, but then later stopped responding, what treatment did your oncologist move you to next?

Thanks, and all my love to all of you.


Login or register to post replies.

sallyandree's picture
Replies 2
Last reply 7/18/2016 - 5:12pm
Replies by: AshleyS, Polymath

Has anyone taking Opdivo and Yervoy experienced a tumor getting larger and later decreasing in size?  Specifically, has anyone had a PET scan after taking several months of Opdivo and Yervoy treatments indicating that the tumor increased in size, and thereafter had scans indicating that the tumor had decreased in size?

Login or register to post replies.

gigembritt's picture
Replies 3
Last reply 7/16/2016 - 12:27pm
Replies by: Janner, Anonymous, gigembritt

Well I had my first apt at MD Anderson. Dr. Ross did a punch biopsy where my shave initally was.  We have surgery scheduled on the 27th.

Depending on this path report determins if we go ahead with the SLNB and WLE or just the WLE... right now we have both scheduled..... but he said we may be able to get away with not doing the SLNB....just sucks since we cant tell depth with the stupid shave biopsy. Eased me nerves a little since he seemed to not be too worried... but now I have 4 stitches were the punch biopsy was taken......and more waiting. 

Login or register to post replies.

Scooby123's picture
Replies 26
Last reply 7/28/2016 - 5:16pm

Hi guys, went for my scans results treatnent to brain worked tumour shrunk. Tumour to liver lungs no change stable so no treatment needed. 3 month breather till next scans. My heart was jumping out of my chest in the waiting room. So glad got another 3 months to chill.


Login or register to post replies.

Aaron's picture
Replies 6
Last reply 7/18/2016 - 8:30pm

So I am going for my 3rd ipi/nivo combo infusion next week and so far I have experienced two days of rash and 1 day of diarrhea.  Starting to get a little nervous that I may not be a responder since my side effects have been so minimal. I am still experiencing lower back pain like the onset of sciatica.  I have also experienced some anxiety moments. I guess that is what they are. I feel like my blood pressure is through the roof but when I check it it is fine.  Have experienced some pressure/fluttering sensations in lower abdomen where I imagine my tumors to be located but theses feeling have also pretty much subsided.  I know it is possible to not experience side effects and still be getting the desired response but it is a little unnerving because you feel you need to experience something to make you think it is working or that you have earned it. Don't know what kind of response I want. Just putting it out there. 

Login or register to post replies.