MPIP: Melanoma Patients Information Page

The MPIP is the oldest and largest community of people affected by melanoma hosted through the Melanoma Research Foundation. It is designed to provide support and information to caregivers, patients, family and friends. Once you have been touched by melanoma—either as a patient or as a family member or friend of a patient—you become part of a community. It is not a community anyone joins willingly. But if you must be part of this group, you will find no better place to find the tools you need in your journey with this cancer, and the friends who can make that journey more bearable.

The information on the bulletin board is open and accessible to everyone. To add a new topic or to post a reply, you must be a registered user. Please note that you will be able to post both topics and replies anonymously even though you are logged in. All posts must abide by MRF posting policies.

Expand/ Collapse Topic
Replies By
View Topic
Anonymous's picture
Replies 5
Last reply 10/9/2016 - 9:22am
Replies by: Anonymous


My husbands pathology report states the below in the comment section, could someone please help me work out what this means. 

'A difficult meloncytic lesion. There is at least melanoma in situ and in one early level a solitary atypical dermal meloncyte. This is deemed early largely regressed melanoma' 

it is the early large regression which has me confused. 

His report states 0.4mm, no ulceration, mitotic figure 0 per mm2, superficial spreading, radial growth phase, brisk TIL. I know all of these are signs of good prognosis however I can't help but think they aren't true as it had largely regressed therefore could have been deeper/VGP etc

Any advice would be appreciated :-) 

Login or register to post replies.

BrianP's picture
Replies 7
Last reply 10/11/2016 - 5:28pm

Warning:  Long winded post may cause narcolepsy.  Recommend placing pillow near keyboard.

I really enjoyed Julie’s “Update & Plan A & B” post and found it quite helpful.  I was pleased to find our methods were very similar.  Here’s my update and lesson’s learned over the last couple months.  A quick summary for those unfamiliar, I completed a 2 year sequential ipi/nivo combo trial in Aug 15.  At the completion of the trial I had two tumors that had been stable for the last 18 months of the trial and for one year post treatment.  A Petscan on 3 August showed a couple new suspicious nodes with mild uptake.  Due to location of the tumors and some other factors I made the decision not to biopsy and rescan in 8 weeks.  I did that scan last Wednesday which showed increased uptake on those nodes and confirmed my recurrence. 

Waiting the 8 weeks for the second scan was tough mentally but it did allow me some time to see several experts in the field.  Like Julie I did as much research into the science and did a lot of searching on  Here’s a little trick on I found very helpful.  Go to Advanced Search and type in “melanoma” in Search Terms.  Under Recruitment select “Open Studies”.  Select Adult under Eligibility Criteria.  For location select United States (or as appropriate) or you could select between 1 and 3 states near your location.  Under Additional Criteria you could select the Phase trial you are interested in or leave it blank.  Click search and depending on your location criteria you will get 2 or 3+ hundred results.  What I discovered is the “Search Details” tab near the top.  If you open that tab you can then usefully filter your search.  For instance if you are looking for an anti-PD1 trial click the “PD-1” term and it will filter down to only the trials with anti-PD1.  If you are a Stage IVer you can click the “Stage IV melanoma” term and find the trials for stage IV patients.  Maybe I’m the only one that didn’t know that but I’ve been using for a long time and never knew that.

Another lesson I keep relearning is how to prepare for meeting with the melanoma experts.  When I go there with specific questions and objectives for the consult I always come away with more useful information.  If I go there “hoping” they are going to tell me what I need to know I am usually disappointed.  Sometimes after a consult I realize that I’ve received lots of information but the doctor never really said what I should do.  I have to remember the question, “What would you do if you were in my shoes?” question.

So in my specific case I struggled through a few competing treatment thoughts.  As a previous anti-PD1 responder there’s no guarantee but a good chance I would respond a second time.  Do I want to go back to a PD1 drug and hope to get another 1 or 2+ years out of it and hope for new and improved treatments to come along in the future.  The other competing thought was do I try something outside the box and keep PD1 in the back pocket.  And the third competing thought was a compromise between the two where I look for a PD1 + experimental drug combo trial.  I will say I was impressed with the amount of phase I and II trials with PD1 combo.  I think it was Tim Turnham after ASCO 2016 who said we are 1 or 2 years out from the next “big PD-1 like” announcement.  If the number of Phase I and II trials on is any indication I think he is right.

I struggled with the decision but have decided to go with the outside the box option and try the” Cellular Adoptive Immunotherapy Using Autologous CD8+ Antigen-Specific T Cells and Anti-CTLA4” (Josh’s trial).  There’s a few beliefs I’ve had from the beginning of my melanoma journey.  One of those was that I was going to try as many things as I could while I have the ability.  I’ve read so many stories of patients not having success with their first, second, or even third treatment but eventually something worked before they ran out of time.  That also formed one of my other beliefs in the cumulative effects of treatments.  One treatment may not be your solution but it provides just the right amount of impact on your immune system for the next treatment to finish the job.  I also figured this was a good time to try a trial like this where you have to wait up to 8 weeks to start while I still have slow disease progression and low tumor burden. 

Well that’s it for now.  If you made it this far I salute you!



Login or register to post replies.

Happy_girl's picture
Replies 4
Last reply 10/3/2016 - 10:07am

Well- it's almost time.  I get my scan on Monday.  The history- my last scan in June they saw a sub cm spot on my liver.  It was too small to tell what it was ( this was through a ct scan)  my scan before that was a pet - and they didn't see the spot.

my doc (James cancer center - osu-Columbus Ohio) was very positive saying she is fairly certain it is just a cyst - but to rescan just to check.

so now it's time for the rescan and I'm scared to death.  I'm hoping cysts would be common and this is a cyst! I know this isn't really a question- just needs to share! Feel free to let me know your thoughts! 

Oh yeah- I'll be 2 1/2 years ned stage 3a if this scam comes cack clear!!!

Login or register to post replies.

Jenine's picture
Replies 5
Last reply 10/6/2016 - 7:10am
Replies by: Bubbles, Jenine, debwray

Hello All,

Has anyone participated in case study 13-105?  My husband is considering this as an option for treatment. From what I understand it has been in trail phase for 2 years but feedback is limited.  Thanks.

Wishing everyone strength and good health♥️ 


Login or register to post replies.

Anonymous's picture
Replies 4
Last reply 10/3/2016 - 9:57am
Replies by: cancersnewnormal, Anonymous, debwray

About 2 years ago I noticed a pink/brownish bump on my thigh.  It was a small perfect circle. I suffer from ocd and health anxiety so I was constantly poking and prodding at it.  At one point the top got some flaky skin on it.  It never grew and the flaky skin was the only issue.  After looking at thing for 8 months I asked it be removed and the doctor said it looked fine but he would remove it.  It was 4mm and he did a shave biopsy.  

I was told I needed to return to have it excised and was told it was an atypical traumatized spitz Nevus/ differential diagnosis of benign spitz.  The shave apparently got the entire mole because the excision was completely clear.  

I am 34 years old and started researching spitz Nevus and started getting anxiety that it might have been melanoma that they missed.   Spoke to my derm and he put me in touch with the dermatopathologist.  He is university of penn trained and worked under bernard akerman.  He went to great lengths to explain what he saw in my spitz and he said in his trained eyes it was a traumatized spitz Nevus and when I explained that I had been picking at it the doctor said then tgat explains the changes I saw ! Then tried to explain trauma in a mole.  The dermatipathologist said we removed it with clear margins and that is the standard of care.   He said in an adult a diagnosis of a complete benign spitz Nevus can never be made because they have atypical features.   He said get my yearly check ups and that the likely hood that this tiny lesion ever haunts me is almost non existant. 


For those who understahd this stuff it sounds like the only concern he had was the trauma of the spitz and the rest met the criteria for a benign spitz.  Is it reasonable to relax and put this behind me  and why is the trauma significant ? 

Login or register to post replies.

Replies by: Anonymous, Bubbles

Samantha posted some replies to my earlier post even though she was dealing with the passing of Mickey. I am grateful for her contributions (as I am everyone's) on this forum.

From 9-29-16

"Sadly today I will lay my sweetie to rest.  He had passed away at MDAnderson on 9-24. His LMD was under control and he had started the TIL trail for progression in his liver,lungs and lymph nodes.  They did a CT of the chest and abdomen on Sunday  and all was stable. The third day in his blood oxygen were low and blood pressure was low, they did a chest X-ray that showed possible aspiration gave him lasiks then they took him to the ICU where he passed away. They asked if I wanted an autopsy I said no more cuts.

Mickey's LMD was in his spine and they did do radiation there so that maybe way he had to have the flow test both times.  He did the intrathecal with the IL2  but had to stop to get on this trial.  We were going every eight weeks.  In 2013 Mickey developed hydrocephalus (which is a side effect if intrathecal) that was when they put the shunt in.  he had had WBR and two gamma knifes done and by the end of 2015 his brain was getting tired.  He had the intrathecal done in 12-15 and by the time I got him home he could not make his legs move so we went back down there nothing found he got better we went home then the next one after being home an hour he couldn't talk we went to the ER here at home they said it was a seizure. When we went back for the next one Mickey progression had gotten worse so they wanted to try to get him in this trial.

I keep coming back here for the LMD Warriors, I know he would say he would do this treatment all over again. It was bumpy but I would go on the journey again knowing what I know."

Wishes of strength and support go out to you over the next weeks and months Samantha. Always think of Mickey's arms wrapped around you in his warm embrace. From now on every round of Mickey's includes a hole in one.


Even after the warriors have past they continue to contribute to those left behind. As the anniversary of Artie's death (which hit me especially hard even though I had never met him) I find myself reviewing many of his posts in search of pain relief options for Adriana.

My gratitude to all.



Login or register to post replies.

Anonymous's picture
Replies 3
Last reply 9/30/2016 - 9:14pm

I am a 23 year old white male with numerous freckles and moles. After a friend pointed out a very atypical mole on my calf, I went to a dermatologist for a biopsy. I was diagnosed with a melanoma In-situ, and was okay after my dermatologist explained the excellent prognosis. I have had my WLE with clear margins. I went to pick up a copy of my pathology report for my files, and noticed the diagnosis was an "irritated early evolving melanoma in Situ". I am a bit of a hypochondriac, and it worries me that I haven't seen this exact diagnosis with my google searches. When I went in for my WLE, the doctor assured me that it was in situ. Can anyone more knowledgeable than myself explain what the "irritated" component of the diagnosis means? The pathology reports last line reads "there is perivascular lymphocytic inflammation with melanophages". Thanks in advance for your help!

Login or register to post replies.

Replies by: Hukill, debwray, Anonymous

We live in Miami Florida. This week my father who is diabete and 74 yrs old received the following results from his dermatologist.  Any advice and recommendations the first appointment with the oncologist is this monday. I am going with him and I want to be prepare as much as possibe.

Thank you for any information and help you can provide. 

Skin Biopsy, Mid Upper Forehead -
Malignant Melanoma, Clark's level at least IV
Breslow thickness at least 2.8 mm
Ulceration - present
mitoses -<1mm 2 square
panthologic stage - pt3b
Note: the lesion extends to peripheral and deep histologic margins. Pan melanocytic cocktail Mart-1 and tyrosinase) is performed. 

How bad is this?
What is the best possible treatment for this?

Thank you
from his son 

Login or register to post replies.

Jacqueh27's picture
Replies 3
Last reply 10/1/2016 - 8:10am
Replies by: Anonymous, Maria C, Becky

It has been a long time since I have posted, but I wanted to report that my daughter Jessica, who had a 14 cm on her liver two years ago, has finally had her liver resected and has NO evidence of disease!!! This will be her third time cheating death as she was diagnosed at 20 and has had initial mole removed, lymphectocmy and now half of her liver.(she is now 26) She has been on Yervoy, Keytruda, Obdivio, Y90 Radiation crystals, had three embolizations and then Braf Inhibors. While this fight for her was long and grueling, she never gave up. We are thrilled with the results and pray she will stay melanoma free for years to come. Never give up!!!! Mayo Clinic in Jacksonville, Florida saved her life!

Login or register to post replies.

snow white's picture
Replies 14
Last reply 9/30/2016 - 9:23pm

I am just wondering if placing a Port O Cath is normal when undergoing treatment.  I know when I was going through chemo 4 years ago, I had 18 treatments and had a Port that made things much easier.

Is this also the protocall for Melanoma treatment?


Login or register to post replies.

Ross&#039;s.Mom's picture
Replies 9
Last reply 10/14/2016 - 6:10pm

Our 11-year old son, Ross, was diagnosed on 9/14/16 with melanoma on his ear. His slide has been seen at Mayo and UCSF and he is currently being treated at University of Iowa Children's Hospital. We met with Dr.Mo today- melanoma specialist in Iowa. Here's what I know from path report: Breslows thickness 2.4mm, Clark's level IV, mitotic index 5/mm(2), margins positive (melanoma focally present at deep margins), stage T3a. He is scheduled for wide excision and SLNB this coming Tuesday, 10/4. I'm deeply concerned about the lack of research on melanoma in children. Dr. Mo said about 10 cases/year in the US- that cannot be right!!?? We're still sort of in disbelief. Can this be happening??

Login or register to post replies.

Maria C's picture
Replies 6
Last reply 10/3/2016 - 5:13pm

Hi all,

Yesterday I had my third infusion of pembro and am dead tired today, with an achy body. We restarted immunotherapy after a summer (June - August) dealing with brain mets recurrences that have left my scalp very sore and tender from the radiation. I've also had all 4 ipi-nivo infusions last year.

What confuses me is trying to identify what are side effects from the immunotherapy and what are just "normal" health issues. For instance, I've had hot & cold flashes for many months now, and believe I am in menopause (I'm at that age). However, reading these boards I have learned that others experience fevers and chills (at any age). In addition, my knees ache today like I've got the flu, plus I walked all over the city yesterday surrounding doctor appointments ... but I've read on these boards that "joint pain" is a common side effect.

Also I noticed my feet occasionally feel differently lately but it's NOT tingling. Am I imagining symptoms or are they real? How do we know what's what?

Any & all thoughts appreciated!

Maria - Stage IV, MM, brain mets, responder to ipi/nivo combo

Login or register to post replies.

cancersnewnormal's picture
Replies 26
Last reply 10/9/2016 - 12:32pm

Hi all!

I was on Keytruda for 20 months. It worked quite well for me, including a stoppage of any new brain mets! In July, i began having pancreatic issues, and we stopped/paused infusions. My brain scan as of 4 weeks ago, is clear, so it seems as though the immune response continues. WHEW! Although my pancreatitis cleared up, and the enzyme levels have gone back down, I'm now finding myself with joint/muscle pain, and the ever so annoying sinusitis. I've had a stuffy nose since early August, and I snore like a grizzly bear, even when wearing a breathe right strip! Thus far, the joint pain has been "contollable" with over the counter NSAIDS. There are days though, when the pain is too high for normal daily function. We're blood testing for Lupus and rheumatoid issues. Tests showing inflammation came back as out of range high, but not crazy high. 

My questions...... Has anyone had these same kinds of issues? As for treatment of them... did discontinuing immuno infusions do the trick? Were you able to "spot treat" body areas (ex. knee or nose), or did you have to rely upon systemic steroids? I'm not a fan of how the dex makes me feel, and I am concerned about systemically slowing the immune response, because I absolutely fear the return of brain mets. However... something has got to give.

-- Niki

Login or register to post replies.

Anonymous's picture
Replies 6
Last reply 9/30/2016 - 4:30pm
Replies by: Bubbles, Anonymous, BrianP

Hey, so I did IPI, but it came back in my lungs. Started Keytruda but two months later ended up in the hospital unable to breathe.

Dr. switched me immediately to debrafenib + mekinist combo, which relieved the pain immediately, but I know this is only a temporary bandaid.

Are there any options for long-term results after failing IPI and PD-1? Are there any promissing new trials in the pipeline?

Any long-term lung survivors after failing immune therapy?

Login or register to post replies.

KAF's picture
Replies 10
Last reply 10/6/2016 - 9:49am

Hi all

I developed hypophysitis 1 week after my 3rd dose of ipi/nivo in mid July.  I've been on steroids, was weaned down when pituitary became inflamed again.  I went back on hi-dose steroids (100mg) a couple of weeks ago and now I'm down to 40mg.  I'm hoping to continue lowering that number but monday night (3am tuesday) I woke with what felt like flu- 103.2 fever and horrible chills.  I took advil and I felt fine the rest of the day except for fluctuating between chills & sweats during the day. The fever didn't come back during the day.  I have no sore throat, cold, or any other symptom that would make it seem like a flu.  Yesterday morning I woke up at 4am with a fever of 103.4 and chills again. I took advil, felt fine the rest of the day and the fever went away.  This morning about 2am my fever came back - 101.2 - and the chills weren't so bad but the muscle aches were painful.  The advil took the fever down and got rid of the muscle aches but my hands are tingly today and my vision is horrible today and I can barely read what I'm typing.

I called my doc and spoke with the nurse.  She thinks these are all side affects from the ipi since i've only been off it since mid july and she said this can happen after the treament is done.  I would have just thought that the hi dose steroid i'm on would have stopped the drug from all these side affect.  Does that mean the drug is still working in my system even while on the steroids?



Login or register to post replies.